- Making the Most of Your Smart Home: Common Use Cases - March 28, 2023
- Eco Mode at Night: Maximizing Nest’s Energy Savings - March 20, 2023
- Connecting & Controlling Smart Home Devices: A Guide - March 18, 2023
Disclosure: Links marked with * are Affiliate Links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases if you decide to make a purchase through these links – at no cost for you!
The Echo 3* and Echo 4* are devices that score points for their versatile features. The latest generation from Amazon comes up with a number of innovations.
If you are thinking about getting one of these two models, you should familiarize yourself with their characteristics. In this way, you will find a device that suits you and your needs.
Are the features and usability of the Echo 3 or Echo 4 better? That question cannot be answered in general – this depends on your preferences.
In this article, the advantages and disadvantages of the two Echo models are clearly presented. In this way, you will be able to make a well-thought-out choice. The article is intended to help you with your purchase, which is especially practical for laymen.
First of all, there is a comparison table of the most important technical properties:
| Echo 4 | Echo 3 | |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 144 x 144 x 133 mm | 148 x 99 x 99 mm |
| Weight | 970 g | 780 g |
| WLAN | 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac | 802.11a/b/g/n/ac |
| Bluetooth | Yes | Yes |
| Audio | 76.2 mm neodymium woofer and two 20 mm tweeters | 76.2 mm neodymium woofer and 20 mm tweeter |
Table of Contents
The Most Important Differences at a Glance
The new generation of the Echo features a completely new design. From now on the Echo 4 is no longer cylindrical but spherical. But also in terms of functions and equipment, a lot has changed. The most important differences will be presented to you in this article.
The Design
Both devices have the following dimensions:
- Echo 3: 148 x 99 x 99 millimeters, 790 grams
- Echo 4: 144 x 144 x 133 millimeters, 970 grams
At first glance, it is noticeable that the latest version of the Echo has not only become larger but also somewhat heavier. So you have to plan for more space for the device – for this, the 4th generation is not quite as high as its predecessor.
The more powerful speakers of the Echo 4 are responsible for the fact that the device weighs more than the Echo 3.
Both devices are covered with a layer of fabric. An innovation in the 4th generation is the integration of the control buttons in that layer. The Echo 3 has a hard plastic layer at the upper end. This makes the new model look more elegant. Ultimately, however, the preference for a certain design is in the eye of the beholder.
On the old loudspeaker, Alexa’s light ring is located on the top, while it is located at the bottom of the Echo 4.
However, this has a disadvantage – the ring is no longer completely visible due to the new positioning. So sometimes you have to look closely to see a possible color change.
In terms of color, there is an innovation – the Echo 4 is now also available in white. Apart from that, you can choose between the colors blue and charcoal for both models. This gives you the opportunity to buy an Echo that suits you and your interior.
Sound Quality and Speakers
The following speakers are built into the individual models:
- Echo 3: 0.8″ tweeter, 3.0″ woofer
- Echo 4: 2 x 0.8-inch tweeter, 3.0-inch woofer
The biggest advancement is the integration of a second tweeter in the Echo 4, which makes the sound richer but more directional. The latter aspect turns out to be a small disadvantage. This is because the Echo 3 has a 360 degree sound. This means that it doesn’t matter where you place the unit in the room – it ensures a consistent sound.
In terms of range, the Echo 4 is a big improvement. The loudspeaker is now easy to hear even from a distance, which is especially advantageous if you want to place it in a larger room. In this context, the stereo separation should also be mentioned. This ensures that the loudspeaker adapts the music to the acoustics of the room.
Both the Echo 3 and Echo 4 are operated with Dolby. In the latest version, stereo has been added – which means that it now sounds more dynamic than its predecessor.
Smart Home Connectivity
Many users use Echo devices to control smart home components. In this respect, the two devices are equipped with the following functions:
- Echo 3: Alexa voice control
- Echo 4: ZigBee, Sidewalk, BLE Mesh, Alexa voice control
So you can see that in terms of smart home connectivity, the Echo 4 offers a significant expansion in features. Common to both devices is the Alexa voice control.
This one already offers a wide range of functions. The latest generation of the Echo has also been equipped with ZigBee, Sidewalk and BLE Mesh. This gives you the ability to control all your smart home devices easily and smoothly.
The ZigBee controller and Amazon Sidewalk should also be mentioned. With these components, you have the possibility to connect devices directly via the Echo in order to control them via the ZigBee controller. Amazon Sidewalk has increased the range of the product. It also allows you to control smart home devices even when the WLAN is down. So you always remain flexible when operating the system. With the Echo 4, you can even connect to the end of your garden, which is especially useful for motion sensors.
The Bluetooth meshing further improves the connection to the smart home system during the Echo 4.
When it comes to smart home connectivity, the Echo 4* clearly leads the way. This model makes it possible to establish a solid connection to smart devices even over longer distances. In addition, the wide range of integrated functions means you are no longer exclusively dependent on WLAN. If you want to use the Echo primarily for smart home control, you should choose the latest product variant.
The Costs
When it comes to the price, the Echo 3 performs significantly better. Because the costs are significantly lower compared to the successor. They are particularly impressive when it comes to the versatile equipment. Although the functions of the older version are not quite as extensive as those of the Echo 4, they are still impressive.
If you want to save additional money, you should look for promotions and discounts at the dealer of your choice. It is also advisable to take a closer look at the products of several suppliers. This will enable you to make a well-thought-out choice.
Echo 3: Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages:
One of the biggest plus points of the Echo 3* is the good price-performance ratio. Despite the extensive equipment, the costs are within the affordable range. This proves to be especially practical for beginners who have no previous experience with Echo devices.
Furthermore, you can enjoy 360-degree sound with the Echo 3. This distributes the music evenly in the room and thus provides a harmonious sound experience.
The older version also has some advantages in terms of design. The device is characterized by its compact size. It also proves to be comparatively light. Since the Alexa ring is located on the top of the Echo 3, it is easy to see from almost any position.
Disadvantages:
The sound quality cannot keep up with the Echo 4. So you will have to cut back when playing music, especially in large rooms. But for compact rooms the sound is sufficient.
Even when it comes to smart home connectivity, the device lags behind the Echo 4 in terms of features. You can control your smart devices on the Echo 3 with Alexa alone. A working WLAN is essential for this. If it fails, you won’t be able to control your smart home system with the Echo. If a more extensive equipment is important to you in this respect, you should choose the 4th generation model.
Echo 4: Advantages and Disadvantages
Advantages:
With the successor of the Echo 3, you will enjoy a modern design. The spherical shape looks futuristic and noble at the same time. The device also has a solid stand and does not tip over so easily when loaded on one side.
The sound quality of the product can also be seen. Although it does not have the 360-degree sound, the tones sound purer. This is especially noticeable in the higher volumes. The Echo 4 is also able to adapt to the acoustics of the room. This is a particular advantage in large rooms. Thanks to the improved range of the new Echo device, you can also enjoy a rich sound.
But the biggest plus point is the equipment in terms of smart home control. In that device, the functions ZigBee, Sidewalk, BLE Mesh and the Alexa voice control are integrated. This not only ensures an improved range but also means that you no longer have to rely solely on a functioning WLAN when operating the system. If you want to use the Echo primarily for Smart Home, you should purchase the 4th generation.
Disadvantages:
Due to the versatile equipment, the price for the Echo 4 is relatively high. In this case, you have to expect expenses in the three-digit range. But even here it can be worthwhile to compare the costs with several dealers.
In terms of design, the positioning of the Alexa ring on the bottom of the device is a disadvantage. Because there it is no longer completely visible. So users sometimes have to look a little closer to see the color – this is especially true at a greater distance from the echo.
Further Information
Where can I buy an Echo 3 or Echo 4?
If you want to buy one of the devices, you should first go on the Internet. Here you will find a large selection of dealers. This is especially useful if you want to compare prices. But before you decide on a particular seller, you should make sure that the seller is a reputable one. Take a look at the order conditions and make sure that they grant you the right to return or exchange the product.
If the quality of the device does not meet your expectations, you can always return it. This should not result in any additional expenses for you. If you have any questions, please contact the retailer in advance – this will give you a first impression of their customer service. On this basis, you will be able to make a well-thought-out decision.
Of course, you can also buy the Echo 4 or Echo 3 at your local dealer. This proves to be a good option if you want to get a first impression of both models on site. Sometimes you can test some of the functions and sound quality in the store. However, you have a little less leeway when it comes to pricing.
Who do we recommend the Echo 3 or Echo 4?
Whether one of the models is suitable for you, you have to find out for yourself. It always depends on how you use the device and which functions you want to use. But if it is important to you to buy a powerful product that offers you increased comfort and entertainment, then the Echo is the right choice. The latest version has an even clearer sound than its predecessor. Which design suits you better, however, depends entirely on your preferences.
Related Questions
Can Alexa also be operated without WiFi/WLAN?
This question can be answered with a clear “No.”. Because a functioning Internet connection is a prerequisite for voice control. This is because the program obtains all its data and functions from the cloud.
So before you buy an Amazon Echo, make sure that the WLAN connection in your apartment is strong enough. Think about where you want to place the device and check the internet connection – this is easily done with your smartphone.
Related Post:
How to Make a Smart Home with Alexa – Complete Guide
Can the microphone be switched off at the echo?
Yes, you can always turn off the microphone on the Echo 3 or Echo 4. Just press the microphone button on the device. After that, the Alexaring turns red and the echo does not react to the action button or your activation word. You can still send commands to Alexa with the voice remote control.
Is it possible to change the activation word?
This option is especially interesting for people in whose environment someone has a first name similar to the word “Alexa”. You can therefore change the activation word at any time. To do so, call the Alexa app. There you go to the settings – you can choose between the words “Computer”, “Alexa”, “Echo” or “Amazon”.
Is Alexa capable of learning?
Yes, the software adapts to you and your daily rhythm. It also learns through communication. In addition, the speech recognition is regularly expanded and updated by the developer.
Conclusion
Starting with the Echo 3* or Echo 4* depends on how you want to use the device. If you are not too familiar with the Amazon Echo products and are looking for a relatively cheap solution, you are better off with the older version. It still offers you extensive functions and a good sound. You can even use the device to control your smart home devices.
However, if you are looking for an Echo product that shines with innovative features, the 4th generation is the right choice for you. Not only is the sound impressive, but it also ensures maximum connectivity when operating smart home systems. You can control your devices even from a great distance. But you also have to accept higher costs.
If you are not sure about your choice, you should seek advice from an expert. Today, this is possible both online and in specialized shops.
Attention: When installing electronic equipment, please be sure to observe the manufacturer’s safety instructions. You have to take care of your own safety. The information on this site only helps you to learn.
Disclosure: This website is the property of Martin Lütkemeyer and is operated by Martin Lütkemeyer. Martin Lütkemeyer is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Affiliate Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to enable Web sites to earn advertising revenue through advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Links marked with * are affiliate links.